P.O. Box 111, Duluth, MN 55801

TEL: (218) 740-3175 FAX: (218) 740-3179 EMAIL info@MnResponsibleRec.org

WEBSITE: www.MnResponsibleRec.org

Case Studies of Systemic Failure of

Minnesota’s Motorized Recreation Funding Program

April 6, 2004

On December 23, 2003 the St. Louis County Board voted off the agenda and without public notice or comment to recommend conversion of the North Shore State Trail to ATV use. Rep. David Dill testified in defense of this decision at the board’s next meeting declaring that ATV and snowmobile clubs should get what they want because they are "volunteer" run. Accustomed to following the money trail MRR soon discovered that Rep. David Dill himself was enjoying substantial, personal, financial gain as "Trail Administrator" of his own snowmobile club and that he appears to be involved in a number of conflicts of interest regarding these funds.

On March 16, 2004 MRR filed a complaint with the Minnesota State Auditor regarding potential conflicts of interest and misuse of public trail funds involving Rep. David Dill, Voyageur Trail Society, and the City of Orr. Documents involved in that complaint and recent press accounts are provided below.

In the coming weeks MRR will be presenting four examples of evidence of widespread, systemic failure in the DNR’s motorized recreation funding program.

Case # 1: Rep. David Dill, the Voyageur Trail Society and the City of Orr

March 17, 2004 MRR Press Release State Investigation Requested of Rep. David Dill’s Snowmobile Club

March 18, 2004 Duluth News Tribune article

March 19, 2004 Timberjay News article

March 22, 2004 MRR press release MRR calls on DNR to withhold public trail funds from City of Orr

March 22, 2004 MRR Letter to DNR Commissioner Gene Merriam   

March 26, 2004 Duluth News Tribune article

Motorized "Volunteers?" Not!
On January 6, 2004 Rep. David Dill testified before the St. Louis County Board, that snowmobile and ATV clubs are "volunteer" run. A request for public information reveals Rep. Dill’s testimony to be gross misrepresentation for in fact, as "Trail Administrator" of Voyageur Trail Society snowmobile club he has received substantial, personal, financial gain.

David Dill has enjoyed substantial personal financial gain in payments from VTSI:

Public trail funds being misused?

Northern Minnesota state Representative David Dill, who recently testified before the St. Louis County Board that snowmobile and ATV clubs are "volunteer" run, appears to have been caught with his hand in the public till, "double-dipping," and using public trail funds to pay off pull-tab gambling arrangements with the local American Legion. Rep. Dill, was recently earning at least $40,000 a year as a snowmobile club "volunteer", getting his family health insurance paid by the club, and billing the city and the club for the same trips in his car and private plan for meetings that appear to not even have occurred. Minnesotans for Responsible Recreation says this situation reveals a tip of the iceberg in which club members have been paying themselves with public funds for decades.

Conflict of Interest a Way of Life with Minnesota’s Motorized Money

MRR requests for information increasingly reveal that it is common place that the paid Trail Administrators who receive public trail funds for snowmobile and ATV clubs are often also employed by the same local government sponsors who are charged with overseeing the club’s use of these public funds. A 2003 state audit (below) recommends that local government sponsors should be prohibited from assigning oversight responsibility to staff who are officers or bookkeepers of the club." The City of Orr is the local government sponsor and fiscal agent for Voyageur Trail Society. Representative David Dill is simultaneously the City of Administrator of Orr and Trail Administrator of VTSI. In fact, review of 10 years of VTSI documents reveal that Dave Dill and VTSI are one in the same. Public funding requests, club minutes, and proposals are almost all authored by Dave Dill. Dave Dill keeps club files on his computer in the city office. Concerns that Dills dual role in both the city and snowmobile club could compromise the city’s ability to hold the club accountable for misuse of public funds is one thing that prompted MRR to seek the current State Auditor investigation.

Many Believe City of Orr fired Clerk for Providing Public Information

If fiscal agent staff who provide public information that raises questions are fired, who will oversee the use of Minnesota’s public trail funds?

April 5, 2004 Timberjay News

April 3, 2004 Duluth News-Tribune

State audit warned that snowmobile and ATV clubs are "left to operate largely on their own": Environmental Damage, Trespass, Misuse of Funds Guaranteed

A 2003 Minnesota Office of the Legislative Auditor Evaluation Report of State-funded trails for Motorized Recreation found that publicly funded snowmobile and ATV clubs are encroaching on wetlands, trespassing on private property, and operating without oversight or accountability. The audit recommends a schedule of reductions for clubs whom "violate the terms of their grants, or state, federal, or local laws."

More to come from MRR on the 
Motorized Money Trail

In the coming weeks, MRR will be citing four examples where clubs have damaged public and private land with public trail money. Brown says the DNR’s first effort in Northeast Minnesota, to designate the Moosewalk/Mooserun ATV Trail in the Finland State Forest was a disaster. Silver Trail Riders which co-mingles public snowmobile and ATV funds had just caused major damage on the trail. The U.S. Corp of Engineers found, that the club committed 30 "unauthorized impacts" in wetlands. A 50-foot wide trail was bulldozed along trout stream with spoil piles pushed into the riparian zone. An entire wetland of undetermined size was killed when a bulldozed trail impounded water in the wetland, virtually drowning the nearby forest. To everyone’s surprise, instead of holding the Silver Trail Riders snowmobile/ATV club accountable, the DNR went ahead and filled an additional 6.3 acres of wetlands to finish the job.