Chequamegon-Nicolet N. F.
Forest Plan Revision
Talking Points
MRR recommends Alternative 4 which emphasizes more
semi-primitive non-motorized forms of recreation.
Our concerns:
* It is important that ATV routes be included in road density
analysis. ATV routes essentially come with the same characteristics and
impacts of any other route or road used by motor vehicles
* The Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest must inventory and close
all unauthorized, user-created ATV routes on the forest. Only after a
thorough environmental review should any user-created routes be considered for
continued motorized use. In addition, it is necessary to inventory these
user-created, cross-country routes to make monitoring and enforcement of ATV
rules possible. Without a thorough knowledge of where these user-created
routes are, it will be difficult to enforce the new provision which prohibits
cross-country or off-road travel by motorized vehicles including ATVs.
* MRR believes that the current number of trails already existing on the
Chequamegon-Nicolet National Forest is more than adequate to satisfy current
demand for ATV use on the forest. We therefore fully support Alternative
4 which proposes no new trail miles on either the Chequamegon or Nicolet
National Forests.
* The Forest Service must recognize and address the effect of ATV use on
wildlife habitat, particularly the impacts from ATV routes making safe and
secure areas for species much smaller, increasing the ease for poachers to
access game species, and the fragmentation of habitats from ATV designated and
user created informal routes. Nowhere in the forest plan is the
significant negative impact of ATV use on wildlife addressed.
* When addressing the regions social and economic impacts, the
Forest Service fails to look at the potential negative impact of ATV use on
the regions social and economic sustainability in the spring, summer and fall
seasons. The increase in noise and pollution from these machines may
likely drive away traditional visitors to this region who seek quiet places to
picnic, fish and hike free from the noise and fumes of these machines.
People traditionally come to Northern Wisconsin in the spring, summer and fall
to smell the fresh pine needles and hear the call of the Loon across a lake,
not smell exhaust fumes and hear the noise of a revving engine. For
many, the traditional reason for getting away from the city to Northern
Wisconsin will be lost in the cacophony of engines and exhaust, hurting local
economies that relied on the fisherman, hiker and sightseer.